wend

"to follow a series of curves and turns."

Review: On the Calculation of Volume V

Book Specs 📖

  • Author: Solvej Balle
  • Translator: Sophia Hersi Smith & Jennifer Russell
  • Genre: Literary/Science Fiction
  • Publisher: New Directions
  • Pages: 188

One Sentence Synopsis🔖

Ol’ November 18 with new characters, new headquarters, new categories, new research, new loves.

Notes/Thoughts📝

  • NGL being able to read the book before November 18 was not cool and did not deliver the dopamine I deserved after waiting months! Make the wait worth it, damn it!!
  • On Pacing–This was very interesting because the first 70 pages felt ridiculously slow and viscous to the point of disinterest. It wasn’t until I hit Gita’s speech in the auditorium that the book started to pick up speed and I was hooked again. Maybe that’s the benefit of having trust in an author over the course of a series…you give parts of the book the benefit of the doubt that you wouldn’t give to others, and there is flexibility on the author’s part to play with tempo, structure, etc. over time, like creating a sense of apathy feels vs. momentum. Super super cool!!!!
  • On knowledge, research, and categories –most of the book was focused on the organization of knowledge into categories. This is very relevant at this time in my life because at work I am dealing with a similar problem of understanding where “knowledge” from different HR groups sit so that we can structure/connect to these bases in a new experience.
    • There is first the distinction between knowledge, which should adhere to categories and research, which should not. Research stumbles where it wants and the output can become “knowledge” but can also be something interesting worth pursuing.
    • Also discussed was what would be considered knowledge, which could include conjectures, speculations, reflections, drafts, sketches, outlines, experiences, inquiries, analyses, etc. There was the suggestion that “category is hierarchy” but Gita also asserts that the categories should not be in competition with each other; rather, each should add to the growing compendium of knowledge/truth
    • Media Literacy –Lenk posits that in order for our knowledge to be fool-proof and legitimate, we must not exclude participation which he references the “vegetables’ as a basic need for humans, for truth. I think about forums of truth and what we establish as the immutable truth like textbooks, scholarly articles, and more and more now, AI as it continues to improve (scary). The question “Who is to be excluded?” rings in my ears as we rely more on algos and less on our ability to discern and think critically.
  • Chani’s lecture on criticism of evolutionary theory–this one was wild for me although I’m sure it’s been discussed tediously in academic circles. The argument that we select not only the strongest or best-adapted for survival but also the weaker variations that become valuable when the environment changes lit up a neural pathway in my thinking. Variation is a long-term survival strategy and strengths and weaknesses are only time/context dependent explain why the strong don’t always pair with the strong. We help the weak/unfortunately because subconsciously these are pairings that allow us to survive in a different time and continue our lineage as a human race. WOW i’m so mindblown
  • On letting go:’) –This is BIG because it took almost five books for Tara to let go of her grief for Thomas. And because I’ve followed Tara from the beginning, the relief was so needed against the heavy forlornness expressed from the previous books. To see her love again or at least open her heart to new romantic encounters gave my own heart a little hope for the future. This part!!!: “My field of vision has widened, my circles have grown larger. Or lighter. My circles have become lighter. My movements have become lighter, insect-like, flitting around. my thought-circles. My love-circles. Everything growing.” Dudeeeee
  • How dare y’all make me wait for the next book :'(!!!!!!!!

“”

…how slight a change is enough to sever the connection?

I thought that it’s no use longing for places when you’ve left them behind. You’ve got to long for something else instead.

Research must have required beauty…And good craftsmanship…Without beauty, no knowledge, no progress.

It would be a sad thing indeed if we could not burst into laughter while we waited. Or while we tried to prevent everything from going wrong.

…it is evident that we want something more. That we must investigate things. It is an impulse, a joy, a need.

To resign does not mean to come to a standstill. To resign means to remove the seal from a letter. Resignare. To break the seal and see what is written inside. To resign is to open something, not to petrify or atomize or freeze.

…how fortunate we are. We have been given the key to a door one is not usually handed the key to. The door of repetition. The door of observation. The door of insight. The tree of knowledge, if you will.

So what are your options? You can leave your cave, or you can keep sitting there and settle for watching the shadows. You can accept the freedom offered to you, or you can allow yourself to remain in bonds.

We cannot always find replacements for what was destroyed or removed before we arrived, but we can rearrange the patterns, draw new lines, and collect shards for the mosaics.

Finding the right category is like tuning an instrument. When an insight has landed in its proper place, the instrument is in tune, and when all the instruments are tuned, the music can begin.

Science poses questions. To ask a question is to expect an answer. But you cannot be both the one who asks the question and the one who decides who may answer. In that case, you have not asked a question at all. In other words, you cannot practice science while also deciding who may participate in it. If you do not ensure that everyone has food–which, practically speaking, means vegetables, the basis of everything–then you have decided that some people are not allowed to participate.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *